‘Litigious climate’ harming public services, says thinktank
The ‘destructive consequences’ of health and education-related litigation have been attacked by influential conservative thinktank the Centre for Policy Studies.
Co-authored by social commentator Frank Furedi, The Social Cost of Litigation aimed to ‘alert policy-makers and public to the non-quantifiable but nevertheless destructive consequences of litigation culture’.
The report’s authors believe ‘best practice’ in the NHS has become conflated with ‘litigation avoidance’. They also argue that the low number of clinical negligence damages ‘approved or set by the court’ (3.2%) is evidence that litigation benefits only ‘greedy lawyers’.
Evidence cited for the damaging effect of claims against schools for injury is more anecdotal. Information for claims in one year for injuries to children amount to £6.7m. Furedi is further critical of teacher unions’ support for injury claims where injury resulted from ‘normal’ activities.
In both health and education, he says that liabilities could affect the desired operation of outsourcing agreements with new publicly-funded providers.
Repeating points made in his previous paper Courting Mistrust, Furedi argues that compensation in the public sector should be separated from tort law. A scheme of no-fault liability would be central to such a change.
The Social Cost of Litigation concludes: ‘A litigious climate inexorably leads to the diminishing of the ethos of public service and a decline in the quality of care in health and in the education of our children.’
- Hundreds attend legal aid protest rally
- Small business spurning legal services – LSB research
- HMRC proposes crackdown on LLP ‘disguised employment’
- PCT will mean the death of Welsh justice, lawyers warn
- Poor will suffer from court fee changes, MoJ warned
- Overwhelming public backing for legal aid: poll
- Fight PI changes, says MASS chair
- Mass meeting of barristers takes a stand on QASA
- Pannone turns to fixed-price mediation post-Jackson
- Grayling asks for quality standard for PCT firms
- 7,000 lawyers to hit the streets for free legal advice
- Saudi Arabia accepts registration of female lawyer
- Don’t worry about Jackson fallout – judge
- North-west paralegal initiative
- French revolution
- ‘Google’ asylum refusals
- Pilot aims to limit clinical negligence solicitors’ fees
- Will-writing could still be regulated
- In-house growth accelerating
- Appeal Court applies Russian law in dispute
- Insurers to revamp third-party code
- Court interpreters reject new contract deal
- European data plan labelled ‘demented’
- Criminal legal aid cuts to reach £370m
- SRA’s popularity slips
- Traffic courts to be set up
- Economy 'testing access to justice'
- MoJ plans crackdown on ‘so-called’ experts
- Midlands ABS issues ‘join us’ offer to insurers
- Law Society Excellence Awards now open for nomination