The perils of perfectionism

A recent Law Society Gazette podcast asked whether law firms are letting women down. I think they are and I would add something that gets left out: perfectionism culture.

 

We talk about perfectionism as an individual responsibility. It is ‘their thing’; they take it too far and they should work on it in their own time. In my experience, the kind that does real damage does not come from inside the person. It is imposed from outside: by a boss, a client, the firm, or it is just ‘how things are done’. The clinical psychologists Hewitt and Flett called this socially prescribed perfectionism, and it is the form most consistently linked to distress.

 

That standard is usually somebody else’s other-oriented perfectionism – the form that sets impossible standards for everyone around them and cannot let anyone else finish anything. And the boss doing that is usually not a villain. Most were very good at the job, got promoted for it and now answer for work they no longer do. What I hear is ‘I don’t trust anyone else to do it as well as I would’. So they don’t, and you get the same draft back four times, nothing ever quite right. The juniors watch, learn that this is what ‘senior’ looks like, and do it too.

 

Day to day, your drafting comes back rewritten and nobody says why. A client changes their mind on Thursday and it lands as your mistake. You are told about the bit that was wrong and nothing about the rest.

 

That is not high standards. People can meet those. What nobody can meet is a standard that keeps going up, because nothing is ever good enough.

 

So you check everything twice and it stops being about the document. With no feedback, you are left guessing and most people guess the worst. You start worrying about being judged for substandard work – about being found out. Underneath sits the belief that checking is the only reason you have done well, so if you stop you will lose it. Nobody gives evidence either way, so it grows.

 

This costs everyone, but most of all whoever has the least room to be wrong, which in most firms is still a woman. Ten years of that and leaving looks sensible, which is usually when a firm says it has a retention problem.

 

None of this gets fixed by resilience training. It gets fixed by telling people what was wrong and what was right. 

 

So, if you are the one sending it back a fourth time, what are you checking for? And have you ever said so, out loud? If nobody tells them what good enough looks like, how are they supposed to stop?

 

Stacy Thomson 

MSc occupational psychology, former NHS mental health nurse, The Performance Club

 

Checklist for using AI safely

The integration of artificial intelligence into our daily lives is becoming increasingly common, but we should exercise caution and a practical approach. AI is not human and its answers should not be mistaken for sound human judgement.

 

It is understandable that people may turn to AI to ask quick, preliminary questions when facing a problem. However, the advice generated by AI can often be misinformed, out of date or entirely made up, and can cause serious problems. Just like when someone has a health problem, they may ask AI for some initial information, but they will then go see a doctor for safe advice or a diagnosis. The same rule applies if they have a legal question. 

 

The Law Society’s new AI practice note gives specific guidance on how lawyers can integrate AI in their practice safely. Solicitors remain accountable for all work with clients and the courts, whether AI has been used or not. If a client brings to a lawyer any AI-generated material, it must be carefully checked before it can be relied upon. More broadly, solicitors can provide protections which AI is incapable of, such as the reassurance of complete client confidentiality and knowing that they are responsible to a regulatory body.

 

While AI can help with time-consuming administrative tasks, it cannot replace the core skills, empathy and experience of legal professionals. Ultimately, anyone facing a legal issue should seek advice from a fully qualified, regulated solicitor to ensure their best interests are being securely and safely looked after.

 

 

Brett Dixon

President, Law Society of England and Wales

 

Savings before reward

As is usual, the Ministry of Justice says that the likely pay rises for judges are not affordable (news, lawgazette.co.uk, 20 October). This is simply a smokescreen. The plain fact of the matter is that, when it comes to performance and bonus reviews, senior civil servants are assessed not by their contribution to justice (which is perhaps just as well) but by how much money they have saved. 

 

In the MoJ world, saving money is the be-all and end-all. In my decades in the judiciary, I wearied of hearing their usual mantra but, as someone once famously said, ‘they would say that, wouldn’t they?’.

 

Dr Stephen Pacey

Judge of the Upper Tribunal (retired), North Muskham, Nottinghamshire

 

Time to rethink fees

From time to time, I administer affidavits and statutory declarations. The fees for this service have been the same since 1993 and are £5 per deponent and £2 per exhibit. Given that it takes at least one unit of time to deal with this, and at my current hourly rate this amounts to £28.80 plus VAT, surely the time has come, after a 33-year delay, to review the fees that solicitors are allowed to charge. Even an increase to £20 per deponent and £5 per exhibit would be reasonable. 

 

Philip Evans

Associate solicitor, Graham & Rosen Solicitors, Hull

 

Baptism of fire

I read Michael Cross’s article on Big Bang at 40 with interest and amusement. I was the lawyer who joined Smith New Court in response to the Gazette advertisement mentioned. I arrived in July 1987, just in time to enjoy the crash of October ’87! 

 

I was their first lawyer and it was a baptism of fire, although it was a fantastic place to work. I ended up on the main board and stayed at Smith New Court until we were acquired in 1995 by Merrill Lynch. 

 

I then became one of the founding partners of the Weil Gotshal London office, which is clearly another story. 

 

Nick Holt

London WC1

Topics