Two magistrates have been sanctioned after they were found to have ‘failed to treat others fairly, courteously and with respect’. 

Magistrates's court sign

Source: GettyImages

Hilary Whiteway, of the Avon and Somerset bench, was subject of a complaint about her conduct while she was presiding over a sitting at Bristol magistrates’ court. She was alleged to have been ‘rude and dismissive’ towards colleagues by making ‘critical remarks, speaking abruptly and displaying frustration’.

A spokesperson for the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office said: ‘The guide to judicial conduct reminds office holders to be courteous, patient, tolerant and punctual, and to respect the dignity of all.

‘The statement of expected behaviour, annexed to the guide, states that office holders should act professionally and courteously at all times, including when under pressure; avoid shouting or snapping; remain patient and tolerant when encountering difficult situations; and be mindful of the impact that their words and behaviour may have on others.’

Whiteway, in her own representations to the JCIO, said she regretted that her colleagues had experienced the sitting in the way she described. She acknowledged that ‘when under pressure, her speech could become abrupt and be perceived as discourteous, even where that had not been her intention’. She denied making critical remarks.

The investigation found Whiteway’s conduct, though not deliberate or calculated, ‘failed to meet the standards of fairness, respect, patience and courtesy expected of a judicial office holder’ and amounted to misconduct. Mr Justice Keehan, on behalf of the lady chief justice, and the lord chancellor issued Whiteway with a formal warning.

Edward Beaman, of the Lancashire bench, was also the subject of a complaint to the JCIO. Beaman was alleged to have made disparaging comments about two court advocates during the court session and, after clearing the court at the end of the day, criticised their preparation and competence.

The advocates reported that they felt ‘significantly upset’, the JCIO said. Beaman, in his representations, said there had been shortcomings in the advocates’ preparation and presentation and he had spoken to them about those shortcomings.

The JCIO said Beaman ‘believed that he was providing supportive and constructive feedback and did not intend to upset or disrespect’ the advocates. He accepted his communication style ‘may have failed’.

An investigation found Beaman’s criticism of the advocates ‘had not been delivered fairly or constructively’ and he had ‘failed to treat others fairly, courteously and with respect’. Beaman was found not to have intended to insult or offend the advocates during the isolated incident, though the investigation took account of the ‘significant impact’ on them.

Mr Justice Keehan, on behalf of the lady chief justice, and the lord chancellor issued Beaman with formal advice.

Sanctions for misconduct by judicial office holders are, in order of severity, formal advice, formal warning, reprimand and removal from office.