Motor finance mis-selling was heralded as potentially the largest consumer redress event since Payment Protection Insurance (PPI), attracting litigation funders, law firms and investors. Legal challenges delaying the Financial Conduct Authority’s redress scheme are now exposing financial strains across the ecosystem built around anticipated payouts.

Challenges to the scheme will be heard between 16 February and 3 March 2027, with judgment expected in the following months. Recoveries are therefore pushed further into 2027, if not 2028. Firms whose borrowing and business plans assumed earlier payments face financial pressure, with knock-on effects for funders and investors.
This is illustrated by the recent failures of Woodville Consultants (pictured) and Fairplane Solicitors, over which Woodville had a charge in respect of its funding of motor finance claims. Reports suggest that Woodville’s loan notes promised fixed quarterly returns and defined repayment dates, irrespective of recoveries on the underlying claims. Yet litigation offers neither a dependable timetable nor a guaranteed outcome.
Woodville reportedly raised over £390m. Its administrators are investigating allegations that new investors’ money funded returns to earlier investors. Those allegations of a Ponzi scheme remain to be established, but the broader question is how fixed payment obligations could reliably be serviced from claims whose timing and value remained uncertain.
Elsewhere, signs of financial pressure are emerging. Nera Capital (formerly Claim Finance & Administration Co Ltd), which funds Barings Ltd and Veritas Solicitors LLP, has reported that funded firms have paused payments during a Solicitors Regulation Authority review. Investors holding Nera Notes reportedly have not received scheduled interest since April 2026.
The late-filed annual accounts of both Barings and Veritas show the strain closer to the motor finance claims themselves. Barings reported a £22m loss for the year to March 2025, £46.3m in net liabilities and £59.4m in secured litigation funding loans carrying interest rates of 28%–37%. Its auditors warned that a ‘material uncertainty exists that may cause significant doubt on the company’s ability to continue as a going concern’.
Veritas reported a £7m loss for the year to November 2025, £30m in net liabilities and £53m in bank loans, almost all of which were litigation funding loans carrying interest rates of 37% and 39%.
These funding terms differ from Nera Capital’s fixed obligations to investors. Barings has an interest-waiver arrangement, while Veritas’ interest payments are contingent on successful resolution of underlying cases during the loan term. Neither firm recognises work in progress where recovery depends on success, so reported losses do not capture the claims’ potential value.
But contingent value is not available cash. The overheads of the business still need financing in the meantime. Ironically, Veritas’ accounts disclose that it obtained finance from Close Brothers to fund its professional indemnity insurance premium.
Both firms are pursuing restructuring of their funding arrangements, with Barings disclosing negotiations over a debt-for-equity swap. Veritas’ accounts describe an advanced restructuring involving rights to future claim proceeds in return for restructuring and settling associated obligations. Its members then intend to transfer the trade and substantially all operating assets to Veritas Lex, with the LLP ceasing its existing trade. This explains why Veritas’ accounts are prepared on a basis other than going concern.
Veritas’ accounts do not expressly attribute the restructuring to delayed motor finance recoveries. Nevertheless, these steps should be viewed against its earlier expectation of significant settlements by the third quarter of 2026.
Delays are also opening a secondary market in funded claim portfolios as early funders seek to reduce exposure and realise their investment. Duplication with claims held by other firms adds uncertainty to potential fees.
Alongside changes to funding arrangements, firms are having to consider alternative routes to recovery. The Court of Appeal’s decision in Angel v Black Horse, permitting multiple motor finance claims on a single claim form, opens the prospect of pursuing recovery through the courts rather than the FCA scheme. Firms will need to advise clients on the relative merits, costs and risks of those routes, while an application for permission to appeal remains outstanding. However, a firm geared to processing FCA scheme claims will face real challenges pivoting to a litigation strategy.
The exposure does not stop with claimants’ representatives. Blue Motor Finance’s administration in July illustrates the risk on the other side. A successful compensation claim is worthless if the respondent cannot pay it. Lender failures add to the pressure on firms with substantial exposure to these lenders in their claim portfolios.
The delay to the FCA redress scheme does not allow lenders to put preparations on hold. Firms must continue preparing for the scheme and comply with rules still in force. They must also plan for the possibility that the redress scheme or parts of it are quashed, leaving no scheme or complaint-handling pause. Lenders would then need to be financially and operationally ready to resolve complaints within the usual statutory timescales, with appropriate financial provisions.
There is, however, a prospect of some earlier recoveries. Barclays Partner Finance has recently confirmed that it will make early settlement offers to some customers. The FCA supports such offers provided customers are offered no less than they would receive under the redress scheme. Where settlements generate fee income and release funds for repayment, they could ease pressure on financially stretched law firms and their funders, particularly if other lenders follow suit. Any relief for firms will depend on the extent of the offers, the repayment terms with lenders and client take-up. However, firms must base their advice on clients’ individual interests rather than on their own need for cash.
Early settlements may provide breathing space, but they do not yet offer a dependable timetable or level of recoveries across the market. Financial pressures remain interconnected, and difficulties at one law firm, funder or lender can affect others along the funding chain. The priority is therefore to use any early recoveries to strengthen financial resilience, while ensuring that financing arrangements and operational plans can withstand further delays and lower-than-anticipated recoveries.
John Adams is an insolvency and civil fraud partner at Level Law, London
























No comments yet