MPs’ plans to revamp a ‘fragmented’ legal services sector envisage a national legal service. Funding proposals include an interest on lawyers’ client account scheme

Health phone operator

When the House of Commons justice select committee embarked on a major access to justice inquiry last year, the cross-party group of members set themselves an ambitious task. The inquiry’s terms of reference covered not just the current state of legal aid provision but, for instance, potential funding sources and whether regulators were meeting their obligations to improve access to justice under the Legal Services Act.

In July, the committee published a devastating critique of the legal aid sector. Yesterday, the committee published the findings of its broader examination of the legal services sector and recommendations to overhaul a ‘fragmented’ system that lacks sufficient funding, consistent coordination and a clear mechanism to ensure justice is accessible. 

The report makes four principal recommendations. The first and arguably most eye-catching recommendation: a national legal service. 

The service would provide people with reliable legal information and identify the most appropriate support (akin to NHS 111), signpost between different services while measuring their demand and capacity, and identify shortfalls in provision and direct resources to address them. 

While the plan sounds ambitious, the committee says a national service can be set up fairly quickly using existing information, services and institutional capacity. 

The second recommendation: potential sources of cash to fund the service. One of the suggestions – tapping the interest on lawyers’ client accounts – has already alarmed the legal profession. But it is not the only one. 

The third recommendation is more unexpected: a new regulatory settlement to support access to justice. Like the 2026 public bodies review, the committee says legal services regulation needs to be improved to help and protect consumers. A single legal regulator is one of the options proposed. 

'The scheme cannot and should not proceed. The proposal is flawed, sets a damaging precedent and conflicts with wider government commitments on growth'

Brett Dixon, Law Society president

The fourth recommendation: review civil litigation funding. Suggestions to ensure private civil litigation remains accessible to those with limited means include expanding the scope of qualified one-way costs shifting, reviewing the scope of fixed recoverable costs, and introducing a proportionate regulatory regime for third-party litigation funding.

While the overarching concept of a national legal service has been widely welcomed and you will be hard-pressed to find a lawyer who does not have a strong view on legal services regulation, the committee’s funding suggestions have rung alarm bells.

The business case for the need to raise extra cash is well known: the Ministry of Justice is an unprotected department that has suffered budget cuts so severe that cash injections in recent years have not been enough to offset the losses.

The committee says the biggest source of income could come from an interest on lawyers’ client account (ILCA) scheme – a proposal the MoJ is already exploring. However, the ministry’s proposed scheme is a source of unease, with not-for-profits fearful that cash earmarked for civil legal support services will cross-subsidise prisons and the wider criminal justice system. This year’s NatWest Legal Benchmarking Report suggests one in 10 firms – many in regional high streets – could go under if ILCA proceeds.

The committee says any scheme must be administered independently of the government, and clarity about the purpose of the scheme and beneficiaries stated clearly. Effective safeguards would be required to protect firms that rely on client interest to keep prices lower or continue offering legal aid services. 

But even with these conditions, the Law Society doubts the ministry can come up with a scheme that would allay everyone’s fears. 

Society president Brett Dixon said: ‘The scheme cannot and should not proceed. The proposal is flawed, sets a damaging precedent and conflicts with wider government commitments on growth. It is unlikely to generate more than a tiny fraction of the sums needed to meaningfully improve the justice system, and it is unlikely to be a significant or reliable new source of revenue. It is simply not fit for purpose.’

Other suggestions likely to attract loud opposition: levies on third-party litigation funding profits and on high-value litigation awards. 

The committee says ‘targeted’ contributions from high-value litigation could support access to justice, provided they do not deter meritorious claims. Any levy on third-party litigation funding profits ‘should be designed so that it captures an appropriate contribution from the commercial returns generated by litigation funding without making otherwise viable claims uneconomic or restricting access to funding’.

The committee was unimpressed with the government’s response to its legal aid report, so will be pleased to hear that the lord chancellor is open to building a national legal service. However, all eyes will be on the government’s response to ILCA and the levy suggestions.