A lawyer who used AI to draft a document which included inaccuracies and citation errors has been banned from representing applicants before the European Court of Human Rights for two years. 

Artificial intelligence search engine

Source: iStock

The Romanian lawyer, who was acting as one of two representatives, submitted observations on the case which ‘contained numerous errors concerning that court’s case law’. Errors included the citation of non-existent cases and existing case law that was irrelevant to the propositions advances or that plainly contradict the submissions they were intended to support.

The lawyer, who was not named by the Strasbourg court, acknowledged she had used artificial intelligence tools to draft the observations and described the mistakes as ‘inaccuracies’ and ‘citation errors’.

The chamber found the lawyer’s submissions ‘contained a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes’ and concluded that her conduct fell short of the professional and ethical duties imposed by the court and also found in domestic law.

Under the court's rules, lawyers have a duty to act as reasonably competent professionals and display a high level of professional prudence before the court. That duty, the chamber found, meant the lawyer should have ‘independently and carefully checked’ all case law references and arguments generated by AI against authoritative sources before submitting them to the court.

The lawyer’s admission that she had not sufficiently checked all the case law she cited was an ‘understatement’ the chamber found. No checks were carried out on some case law references and many of the errors were found to be repetitive and ‘easily detectable by a cursory check’ of the court’s case law database.

The chamber said the lawyer’s conduct caused prejudice to the administration of justice as the ‘errors had meant that the court had had to spend considerable time verifying the observations to initiate proceedings under Rule 44D [which covers exclusion from representation or assisting before the court] and to correspond extensively with other stakeholders’. This was work that was ‘incompatible’ with the court’s real functions under the ECHR.

The lawyer’s conduct was found to meet the ‘exceptional circumstances’ threshold for an advocate or other person to be excluded from representing or assisting a party before the court.