A regular litigator bringing a discrimination claim over a job he was never offered has been ordered to pay £1,000 in costs after double-booking himself for hearings.

But Raymond Bryce’s case against Stoke-On-Trent City Council was allowed to continue by Employment Judge Dimbylow, who ruled that while the conduct was unreasonable it did not justify striking out the claim.
The tribunal heard that Bryce brought a claim for disability discrimination and victimisation against the council after being unsuccessful in a job application. A preliminary hearing before Employment Judge Flood was arranged for 26 January, but Bryce did not appear at the allocated 10am start time.
The claimant made contact to say he would be ready by 11.30am, but he did not rejoin and the hearing was put off until April and then June. Bryce later admitted he was trying to juggle two hearings on the same day: one before Judge Flood and another at Birmingham County Court.
At the June hearing, he faced the same dilemma, having another hearing at Birmingham listed for the same day at 2pm. The tribunal allowed him to take his ‘lunch break’ from 2pm to 3pm so he could attend the other hearing, and he was five minutes late rejoining the employment case.
The tribunal heard that Bryce, 40, had never been an employee of the council but was a law graduate and knew his case well. He was described by Dimbylow as ‘confident, articulate and intelligent’ and as having ‘significant experience’ of conducting cases in the employment tribunal.
Bryce submitted to the tribunal that he was applying for jobs, but he did not expect to work again. According to the ruling, he indicated to the judge that he had a civil restraint order in place against him, and whilst it affected proceedings in the county court it had no effect in the employment tribunal. Judge Dimbylow noted that Bryce was seen as someone who ‘repeatedly filed unmeritorious or vexatious claims’, although he said there was an ‘arguable case’ here which should be allowed to continue.
On the issue of costs, the judge found that Bryce had failed to demonstrate that his disability impeded his ability to communicate with the respondent and the tribunal about the arrangements for the hearings on 26 January and his trying to balance the two hearings.
‘The claimant knew what he was doing and was trying to juggle two cases at different venues at the same time. It was a risk he took.’






















