Bar complaints system biased against men, report suggests

Topics: Regulation and compliance,The Bar

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (6)
  • Save

The Bar Standards Board's complaints process is biased against male barristers, new research appears to show. But the system does not discriminate against black and minority ethnic (BME) barristers, the regulator says. 

A diversity review of the complaints process published today showed that while more BME barristers are the subject of complaints and punished by their regulator, this is down to factors other than ethnicity.

Advertisement

While previous studies had suggested a disparity in the outcome of complaints between BME and white barristers, analysis of the figures in greater depth showed that complaints about BME barristers were more likely to relate to a sole practitioner or an unregistered barrister and more likely to be initiated by the BSB.  

All factors make it more likely for a complaint to be investigated and for disciplinary action to be taken. 

However the new study suggests that gender does ‘significantly predict’ whether complaints are investigated and cases are referred to disciplinary action, even when other factors are taken into account. Figures show that the BSB is less likely to investigate or refer a female barrister than their male counterpart. 

The report suggested that the BSB should ensure there is no gender discrimination in the complaints process.

Sara Jagger, director of professional conduct at the BSB, said: ‘It is pleasing that the report indicates there is no significant difference in complaints-handling between BME and white barristers, however this is an area we will continue to monitor. 

‘We do, however, need to look more carefully at the new findings in relation to the potential issue of gender bias and ensure that we take action to address this.’ 

The BSB said that in response to the findings it would further anonymise its assessment reports to avoid identifying a barrister’s gender, unless directly relevant to the complaint. 

Readers' comments (6)


  • No doubt if this had been the other way around the usual suspects from the Feminist Lawyers Commissar would be screaming blue murder...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • New research 'appears to say' that white male barristers are being discriminated against. That will be a first.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There has to be a first time for everything!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "The BSB said that in response to the findings it would further anonymise its assessment reports to avoid identifying a barrister’s gender, unless directly relevant to the complaint."

    Ahhhhhh I see what you're doing BSB! If we can't accurately measure gender then there's no evidence of discrimination against male barristers. Bravo!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Perhaps we need a quota system to ensure female barristers are more fairly represented in the complaints stats

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • S V I suspect the reality is less interesting - anonymising the subject of the complaint in the report to the decision maker doesn't remove the record of who that person was.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (6)
  • Save

Advertisement

Sign up for email news alerts

Daily Update. Keep abreast of the latest developments that affect the profession

PRACTICES FOR SALE, MERGERS, ACQUISITION & ASSOCIATION

LAW MERGERS BUSINESS FACILITATORS TO THE LEGAL PROFESSION Services Include: Mergers, Sales, Valuations, Practice Development, Feasibility Studies, Consultancy. CONTACT IN CONFIDENCE: Neville or Mack Dinshaw LAW MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS DX 42809 Kingsbury Tel: 020 8204 3600 Fax: 020 8204 4654 Email: neville@lawmergers.co.uk Web: www.lawmergers.co.uk WORLDWIDE CLIENT BASE QUALITY MANAGEMENT ISO9001 Registered Firm

SELLING? MERGING? VALUING? Acquiring? Free information from 01494 483728. raymondafox@aim.com www.BottomLineConsultancy.com or www.SolicitorSupermarket.biz

DUE TO THE retirement of one of two Partners in a Bolton based firm we are now seeking interested parties to join / merge. T/O in excess of £300k. Email rachel@boltonsolicitors.com

SMALL EAST MIDLANDS Practice seeks sale or merger. Good mix of Property, Private Client work with some litigation. Leased premises till beginning of November 2016, minimal dilapidations and willing to move. Turnover £440,000.00 per annum. Contact 07825 632078.

Browse the magazine

Current Issue

The Gazette offers you up-to-the-minute national and international news, opinion, features, in-depth articles plus a jobs and appointments section.

Please click the link below for a digital edition