Costs expert slams £1,000 hourly rates at top commercial firms

Topics: Costs, fees and funding,City

Citygloomy
  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (50)
  • Save

A shortage of competition amongst elite City law firms is causing artificially high fees to go unchallenged, a thinktank claims today.

The Price of Law, a report written by costs expert Jim Diamond for the Centre for Policy Studies thinktank, claimed hourly rates for leading London firms can now exceed £1,000 and are the highest ever recorded.

Advertisement

Diamond says the increasing complexity of UK tax and legal systems is causing prices to rise.

But he also cites a lack of transparency - with no published online rates for commercial legal services - amongst law firms which allows them virtual control over their prices.

Diamond said while the ‘remarkable’ similarity in rates charged by each of the magic circle firms, with a difference of no more than 5%, did not amount to ‘collusion’, it was indicative of a malfunctioning market.

Diamond, who has worked in-house for Clifford Turner (now Clifford Chance) and Allen & Overy over a 30-year career, said steps have to be taken to ensure fair practice in legal procedure.

‘The billable hour is an outdated and unsustainable billing method for legal services to continue,’ said Diamond.

‘Alternative billing methods must be considered and legal procedure must be simplified to ensure that the legal market place thrives in the long term, and the price of law is not punitive.’

Lord Justice Jackson has suggested fixed recoverable costs for all civil claims worth up to £250,000, but this would omit many of the cases worked on by the leading commercial firms.

The report calls for radical changes to the billing and budget protocol, as well as simplified tax laws and greater transparency.

Diamond recommends that legal regulators insist on all law firms publishing hourly rates of their fee-earners, and if necessary that the Office of Fair Trading investigates if there is evidence of perceived or alleged collusion.

Law Society chief executive Catherine Dixon welcomed the report's recognition that the City of London has some of the best legal firms in the world.

'City law firms have built a reputation for excellence over many years and make a significant contribution to the UK economy,' she said.

'The fees charged by City firms reflect the complexity of the work and high standards required by corporations from across the world, which use English law and our firms because we are a centre of legal excellence.

'Many of these firms offer competitive prices. They are highly successful businesses operating in a competitive sector. We should be celebrating their phenomenal success.'

Alasdair Douglas, chairman of the City of London Law Society, vigorously denied any suggestion of anti-competitive behaviour: ‘The top commercial law firms operate in an intensely competitive market - domestically and internationally - with many firms vying for the same work. There is no cartel of a few UK firms sharing the work out between them. In fact at least 30 firms, US- and UK-based, have the scale, international reach and resources to do most commercial work. That high level of competition has a major impact on determining fees.

‘City law firms advise a variety of clients, including multinational companies, financial institutions and governments, in relation to complex legal issues. By contrast, firms that conduct the majority of their work for individual clients or small business would not be seen as city firms. Clients and their lawyers negotiate the appropriate rates and method of charging depending on the work being done; hourly rates, fixed-fee agreements, discounts, premiums and the provision of secondees all being part of the mix. 

‘The typical City firm/client relationship is extremely well-informed; companies’ in-house counsel, many of whom are ex-City lawyers, are very experienced and only pay where they think they receive value for money. The clients will take their instructions elsewhere if they are dissatisfied, and can manage any complaints about the pricing in the same manner.’ 

Readers' comments (50)

  • This guy is hardly the expert that he thinks he is. Charging rates for the big firms are driven by market forces in the same way that they are in other major cities such as NYC. If people/firms didn't pay these rates, they wouldn't be charged. That perhaps doesn't make it right, but the report is stating the obvious. In any event, JD strikes me as essentially biting the hand that has fed him as he trundles off towards the twilight of his career.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I doubt the CMA study into legal services will touch upon this but Anon 7.13am you are absolutely right.

    The market rate is fixed by the payer and for many clients is determined by the savings accrued rather than the costs incurred.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How are the fees "artificially" high?

    Presumably the client seeks a quote which is then accepted. Looks like a properly functioning market to me.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What's the problem? Magic circle rates are hardly an access to justice issue. And why should we publish our rates? They are a matter for negotiation. In high risk cases, or where our advice is needed in a rush, we may charge more. Or we might (and do) provide a lot of advice on agreed (fixed) fees, where any rate quoted would be meaningless. Publishing rates would is counter-intuitive in and era of cutting red tape.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The problem is that those who pay these fees are not the same people as those who earned the money which pays them. NYC, HMG, local authorities, NHS, trustees, company directors, the banks, fund managers, etc etc.

    No one looks after his money better than those whose it was that earned it. Would you pay £1,000 per hour on your own account?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Not defending it but how much per playing hour does a Premiership footballer get paid?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • To state the blindingly obvious what does anyone think their overheads are in the square mile We charge £220 and we are out in the sticks

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What does he expect.We live in a capitalist country with a govnt apparently intent on deregulation.If you operate in a niche market then you can basically charge what you can get away with.Why should lawyers be treated any differently to footballers entertainers or entrepreuners?
    By the way Davd the answer is yes if no one else was capable of doing the work.I thought you would be in favour of this.Your Tory govnt friends certainly are apart from when it comes to lawyers!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I wonder if Mr Osborne is going to involve himself in reducing these costs so Mr Joe Bloggs off the street has equal access to Magic Circle as he does the high street.

    All I have heard over the past few years is that Solicitors need to be more commercial etc... this is commerciality at its best (no criticism) and it is obviously necessary to compete with other hub's.

    Funny how the Gov use inner London Solicitors for legal's when they could get it half as cheap in, say, Hull (who also have some very good lawyers might I add) and save the public purse (PII aside). But its easy when your spending someone else's money.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What work is no one else capable of, Anon 9.29?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10per page20per page50per page

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (50)
  • Save

Advertisement

Sign up for email news alerts

Daily Update. Keep abreast of the latest developments that affect the profession

PRACTICES FOR SALE, MERGERS, ACQUISITION & ASSOCIATION

SELLING? MERGING? VALUING? Acquiring? Free information from 01494 483728. raymondafox@aim.com www.BottomLineConsultancy.com or www.SolicitorSupermarket.biz

Browse the magazine

Current Issue

The Gazette offers you up-to-the-minute national and international news, opinion, features, in-depth articles plus a jobs and appointments section.

Please click the link below for a digital edition