Legislation giving renters more rights was accompanied by dire warnings that it would have unintended consequences. Maria Shahid reports on what happened

The low down 

Getting on the property ladder is harder than ever. The cost of ownership is transforming us from a nation of homeowners to a nation of renters. That has shone a spotlight on the condition of rented property and landlord conduct. It is staggeringly easy to find examples of poor practice and run-down properties. Tenants are evicted for complaining about mould, or simply as prices are hiked to get in a tenant who can pay more. The response was the Renters’ Rights Act 2025, in which law and the economics of residential property collide. Have the legal rights granted by the act led to the unintended consequences that landlord organisations warned against?

It is just over a year since the much-vaunted Renters’ Rights Act 2025 received royal assent, and six months since its central provision – abolishing section 21 ‘no-fault’ evictions and fixed-term tenancies – came into effect.

Described by ministers as the biggest reform of the private rented sector since the late 1980s, the legislation introduced new restrictions on rent increases, rental bidding and rent in advance. The act also included more protections for tenants with pets and stronger measures to prevent discrimination against tenants with children or receiving benefits. 

Phase 1

The new tenancy regime is the first phase of the government’s plans for reform of England’s private rented sector. The second includes a private rented sector (PRS) database, a mandatory national register of private landlords and rental properties in England. In addition, landlords will be required to join the landlord ombudsman service, which will offer tenants a means of redress without going to court. A phased regional introduction of the database is due to start in mid-December.

Concerns were raised that the reforms could affect housing supply through unintended outcomes. The House of Commons committee report Housing conditions in the private rented sector noted that additional compliance costs, administrative burdens and risks for landlords may lead them to sell properties. Or, it suggested, landlords might repurpose properties for short lets, which could ‘exacerbate problems with the supply and affordability of private rented homes’.

‘Now that the act has been in force for over six months, we are seeing potential landlords consider the possibility of letting their property much more carefully,’ says Annabel Dean, partner at Farrer & Co. 

Annabel Dean, Farrer & Co

Annabel Dean, Farrer & Co

Others have noticed a slowdown in market interest from private landlords. ‘Six months on, I haven’t had a single instruction to purchase a residential investment property,’ says Charlie Davidson, senior associate at Edwin Coe. ‘Perhaps that’s the chilling effect of the act. Practically every conversation I have with landlords, agents and clients seems to involve the spectre of the act.’

'Now that the act has been in force for over six months, we are seeing potential landlords consider the possibility of letting their property much more carefully'

Annabel Dean, Farrer & Co

Research in September by the National Residential Landlords Association found that 26% of landlords had sold or are currently selling at least some of their properties as a direct result of the Renters’ Rights Act 2025, with a further 19% considering doing so. 

Meanwhile, analysis by the Letting Partnership found a quarterly reduction of 12.1% in rental stock available for rent. London’s Square Mile was hit hardest, with rental stock falling 42.4%, while Merseyside and Greater Manchester saw drops of 30.5% and 20.5%, respectively.  

For lawyers, this has meant an increase in strategic advice, says Isaac Daughtrey, a senior associate at Fieldfisher. ‘Since the enactment of the act and the abolition of no-fault evictions, our experience is that landlords/lenders are much keener to have strategic advice on their portfolios so that they can make practical, informed decisions at an earlier stage and tie those into broader workstreams (e.g. refinancings).’ However, he says, ‘some uncertainty remains’. 

Student digs

‘One drastic impact of the act which purpose-built student accommodation (PBSA) clients have been grappling with over recent months relates to an unintended consequence of the act’s drafting,’ says Paul  Moran, a partner at Howard Kennedy. ‘Specifically, its interaction with a right of first refusal now benefitting student occupiers pursuant to a common law tenancy under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987.’ 

 

He notes: ‘Prior to the act, the right of first refusal was not available to students.’ As he explains, they typically occupied under an assured shorthold tenancy, which was excluded from the 1987 act. His clients’ disposals programmes are affected by the two-month statutory notice period, which must expire before a sale can be completed.

 

 ‘It also means that for the time being, a cohort of students could buy the freehold instead of a seller’s chosen buyer,’ adds Moran. ‘Any assets which are caught by these unintended consequences now need to go through additional preparation hurdles prior to the sale being agreed.’

 

For lawyers, this has meant more work as they establish whether an asset is affected, and then negotiate commercial terms with prospective buyers.

 

Moran says: ‘The majority of the clients I am acting for have chosen to avoid the headache altogether, and focus disposal programmes on assets which aren’t affected or to structure sale transactions in a way which avoids this legislative position.’

 

There have also been concerns about how the exemption from the new assured periodic tenancy regime under the act will operate in practice for PBSA. 

 

Although qualifying PBSAs can continue to offer fixed-term tenancies, the exemption criteria are complex. ‘The rules require landlords to closely consider both the immediate factual matrix and their broader business models. As a result, we expect to see further commentary from the industry on the application and interpretation of the statutory criteria in the coming months,’ says Isaac Daughtrey, a senior associate at Fieldfisher.

Revenge rent hikes

It is not only landlords and their advisers who worry about the act’s effects. Housing campaigners warned of retaliatory rent rises.

Nye Jones, head of campaigns at Generation Rent, warned: ‘Revenge rent hikes as an eviction process will become a thing.’ There are protections to prevent unfair rent increases. Landlords are only permitted to increase rent once a year, with tenants needing to be given two months’ notice beforehand, and tenants can challenge an increase in the first-tier tribunal. However, Generation Rent has warned that awareness of the process is low.

Answering a parliamentary question tabled in April 2026, Matthew Pennycook, minister of state for housing, communities and local government, noted that the department will ‘ensure that the justice system is well prepared for the implementation of the Renters’ Rights Act’. 

That included, Pennycook said, the act’s potential impact on the First-tier Tribunal (FTT), and that appropriate funding would be in place to ensure the courts and tribunals have the ‘resources and capacity they need to handle the workload that implementation of the act will generate’.

Simmons & Simmons partner John Kelsey, who predominantly acts for larger institutional landlords, notes that ‘there was a lot of nervousness’ from clients about how the section 13 rent increase process would work in practice. ‘That was a big change for the markets to get used to. There was quite a bit of complexity around how to fill out the details of section 13 notices.’ 

Landlords were also concerned that tenants would routinely challenge the process to delay paying the higher rent. However, data published by Savills suggests that, of the tenants who were served a section 13 notice by their landlord to increase rent, fewer than 0.3% referred the proposed increase to the FTT.

David Smith, partner at Bishop & Sewell, believes that the fear of routine challenge before the provisions came into force may have been misplaced. ‘At the moment, cases are being turned around very quickly, so there is not a lot of benefit to tenants going to the FTT for a delay in the increase,’ says Smith. ‘But at the same time, we are only seeing the ones that were turned around quickly, and I am told that where a hearing is needed, that is taking some time.’

Data published by landlordsums.com shows that the monthly number of published decisions on rent challenges has more than tripled since May. In 54% of cases, the rent went up by less than the landlord requested. Only in 26% of cases did it go up by the full amount.

Kelsey notes that while ‘some of the fears about how the tribunal would cope have not been evidenced’, landlords are still trying to find their way around the evidential requirements. ‘People are still trying to work out how to interact with the tribunal and what the best evidence is to substantiate a claim, both on the landlord and tenant side,’ he says. ‘As a firm, we are advising on making sure our clients have a correct understanding of what the rules actually mean.’

Lack of capacity 

Chris Norris

Chris Norris, National Residential Landlords Association

Delays in hearings due to a lack of capacity remain a concern for landlords. Speaking to the Gazette, Chris Norris, chief policy officer at the National Residential Landlords Association, notes: ‘The rent tribunal system faces significant challenges caused by a large-scale shortfall in the resources necessary to deliver swift, effective justice for all parties. Insufficient investment risks worsening delays in the courts, increasing the likelihood that inaccurate decision-making will occur more regularly.’

Rather than relying on the FTT, campaigners such as Generation Rent and Shelter have also called on the government to introduce ‘rent stabilisation measures’. They argue that annual rent caps be introduced, based on the CPI or wage growth, whichever is lower. To date, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has resisted, arguing that rent stabilisation is a form of rent control that could have ‘unintended consequences’ and lead to less investment in the sector.

'The rent tribunal system faces significant challenges caused by a large-scale shortfall in the resources necessary to deliver swift, effective justice for all parties'

Chris Norris, National Residential Landlords Association

Industry body Real Estate: UK welcomed the government’s stance. ‘Internationally, the evidence is clear, rent controls undermine investment and, consequently, restrict housing supply,’ said its chief executive, Vanessa Hale. 

The professional body for estate and letting agents, Propertymark, warned last month that rent controls could lead to slower investment, with landlords leaving the market, as seen in Scotland following temporary rent caps.

Shadow housing secretary Katie Lam has voiced concerns about the ‘massive expansion of tribunal judges setting rents [introducing] rent controls by the back door’.

Rent controls do little to deal with the underlying issues landlords face, warns Davidson, including paying service charges and other administrative costs, and could in fact lead to landlords leaving the market.

FTT hearings: impact of AI

John Kelsey

John Kelsey (pictured), partner at Simmons & Simmons, notes that tenants are increasingly using artificial intelligence to make complaints: ‘There’s no doubt that this has proliferated. When it comes to section 13 notices, you can clearly see in the case reports how some of the evidence that has been put before the tribunal is AI-generated, because some of it is absolute nonsense. So that is generating a huge amount of work and larger institutional landlords do need to take that seriously. Not only do they have to manage their legal risk, but they have got to manage their reputational risk. You read these things and think it is absolute garbage, but there are possibly one or two salient points that you have to deal with.’

A mandatory national database

The Renters’ Rights Act introduces a mandatory national database of private landlords and their properties. This is designed to improve transparency, help tenants make informed choices and enable local authorities to take action against non-compliant landlords. Registration will be phased across England from 15 December 2026, with landlords required to pay an annual fee of £65 per property. 

Lawyers note that the original impact assessment of the Renters’ Rights Bill assumed a registration fee of £28.58 per property every three years, as opposed to the current annual fee of £65. This increase has landed badly with landlords.

The database is going to cause huge problems, Smith believes: ‘It’s been incredibly poorly designed, as well as being impractical to use. It doesn’t have a bulk upload structure either for landlords with more than a few properties.’ 

‘When you add up the cost for the industry as a whole, it comes to about £300m, and the government could have spent a bit of that money in making the database work more efficiently,’ says Kelsey.

He adds: ‘Another concern is what happens when you have a PRS database holding all this information, and you have all these complaints coming in from tenants. Do you have a similar sort of naming and shaming as you currently have with registered social housing providers? For professional landlords, that raises a lot of reputational and legal issues.’

Landlords who do not register and market a property without an active landlord and property entry on the database face fines, with a maximum civil financial penalty of up to £7,000 per breach. Landlords can also be prevented from getting possession of the property if they have not complied.

Rental stats

Housing supply 

Although some landlords have left the sector, the predicted ‘mass exodus’ has not materialised, according to Savills. A July survey of more than 230 prime landlords found that just 11% had disposed of a property, with most reducing their portfolios rather than exiting the market entirely. 

But further regulation is looming. Alongside chancellor John Healey’s recent announcement of a further 2% increase in income tax on property income from April 2027, the extension of the Decent Homes Standard to the private rented sector is due to start in 2035. This will require landlords to meet minimum standards of repair, safety and thermal comfort. Could this all spell the end of smaller and ‘accidental’ private landlords?

‘I think once the Decent Homes Standard comes in, the overheads and the responsibility and liabilities will be too much for most landlords at the amateur end of the market,’ says Kelsey. The reduction in rental housing supply will lead to higher rents, which is already happening, he adds.

Smith agrees: ‘There is an incredible amount of demand. Rents will inevitably rise as landlords face more costs, including the 2% rise on tax on landlord income, which comes into effect in the next tax year.’

‘My concern is what comes next,’ says Davidson. ‘In London, where leasehold flats dominate so much of the investment market, landlords selling in a hurry could also leave owner-occupiers facing some distinctly uncomfortable comparable valuations. One landlord throws in the towel and the neighbours risk being clobbered by it.’

Yet, he adds: ‘For all the predictions of Armageddon, the everyday relationship between good landlords and good tenants hasn’t suddenly collapsed. I suspect the act will change who wants to be a landlord rather than how decent landlords and tenants actually behave.’

 

Maria Shahid is a freelance journalist and founding editor of PropLAW

 

 

  • There are differences in the application of renters’ rights in Wales. A future Gazette article will assess the legislation’s impact there

 

Topics