Grayling sets out new judicial review restrictions

Topics: Legal aid and access to justice,Planning,Courts business,Government

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (1)
  • Save

The government today set out proposals that would limit who is entitled to apply for a judicial review.

A consultation published by the Ministry of Justice proposes restricting the process to those with a ‘direct interest’ in the case.

Advertisement

Justice secretary Chris Grayling said too many legal challenges are causing new building projects to fall by the wayside because of ‘needless’ court proceedings.

His plans will also create a specialist planning court to speed up the legal process and drive out meritless cases which clog up courts.

The MoJ said the proposals are a response to developers’ complaints that legal delays to projects have forced them into financial difficulty and caused some schemes to collapse completely.

Grayling said: ‘We want to make sure judicial review continues its crucial role in holding authorities and others to account, but also that it is used for the right reasons and is not abused by people to cause vexatious delays or to generate publicity for themselves at the expense of ordinary taxpayers.’

Parliament

Source: Thinkstock

The consultation also proposes changing the rules around who has to pay the legal bills for cases so all parties have an equal interest in cutting costs. This could include making applicants who bring unsuccessful cases pay some of the defendant’s bill.

Legal aid funding will be targeted at cases ‘with merit’, although there is little detail in how these cases would be selected.

The appeals process could also be changed so it is possible for them to be considered by the Supreme Court without first going to the Court of Appeal.

According to the MoJ, applications more than doubled from 4,500 in 1998 to 12,400 in 2012, but in 2012 just one in six were granted permission to proceed beyond the first consideration of the application. Of the 422 which went on to a final hearing without being withdrawn or settled in 2011,163 went in favour of the applicant.

For planning cases, the average time to resolve an application which went all the way to a final hearing was 370 days in 2011.

Stuart Andrews, partner at international firm Eversheds, welcomed the proposal for a planning court. ‘We have been calling for a specialist court of this type for some time as it would ease delays that hold up major building projects. The current administrative structure simply doesn’t allow for important planning and environmental cases to be resolved in a timely and effective manner. Not only is the current system bad for the construction sector and wider economy, it has opened the door to tactical claims aimed at frustrating the delivery of important infrastructure projects.’

The consultation runs for eight weeks and closes on 1 November.

Readers' comments (1)

  • Not on a comment on this article, but why has the Gazette got rid of the box (on the home page) which contained the recent comments of readers? The number of comments seems to have decreased significantly since that box was removed. Many of the comments were, of course, rubbish, but some of them did make interesting points.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (1)
  • Save

Hong Kong protest

Hong Kong law chief plays down crisis

20 October 2014By

Justice secretary Rimsky Yuen defends system amid political unrest.

Jeremy Wright

White collar crime reform considered

20 October 2014By

Attorney general tells Gazette of concerns too many directors are avoiding punishment even when their companies have broken the law.

Hywel Francis

Judicial review plans prompt parliamentary alarm

17 October 2014By

Lords will debate Criminal Justice and Courts Bill next week.

Kingsley265x144
Browse over 3,500 law jobs Get jobs by email

Sign up for email news alerts

Daily Update. Keep abreast of the latest developments that affect the profession

Browse the magazine

Current Issue

The Gazette offers you up-to-the-minute national and international news, opinion, features, in-depth articles plus a jobs and appointments section.

Please click the link below for a digital edition