Judge backs Libor trader confiscation order

Topics: City,Money laundering and financial crime

Tom hayes
  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (3)
  • Save

A court has stripped former City trader Tom Hayes (pictured) of more than half of his £1.7m available assets in a confiscation proceeding, a significant win for the Serious Fraud Office’s proceeds of crime division.

The order follows Hayes’ conviction for conspiracy to manipulate the London interbank offered rate (Libor).


Sitting at Southwark Crown Court, Mr Justice Cooke, who also presided over the original criminal trial, ordered Hayes to pay £878,806. Hayes must satisfy the order within a specified period or incur a default prison sentence of three years.

Hayes owns a seven-bedroom family home in Surrey. He transferred half of the property to his wife in 2013 to enable her to take out a mortgage to meet mounting legal fees. Prosecutors told the court that this had been done without informing the SFO, and against the advice of his then-lawyers.

During the confiscation proceedings, the court was asked to consider three questions. Had the defendant benefited from relevant criminal conduct? If so, what was the value of the benefit he obtained? Finally, what sum was recoverable from him?

Commenting on today’s order, Mark Thompson, head of the SFO’s proceeds of crime division, said: ‘The court acknowledged the challenges of quantifying the benefit from crime in this case. The SFO provided the court with all the available information and the outcome is a substantial confiscation order.’

Peter Binning, principal at niche corporate crime firm Corker Binning, told the Gazette the confiscation order was a significant development because the ‘SFO case was not based on actual loss’. As a result, he added, the judgment ‘appears to have done something quite dramatic’.

The SFO had originally sought to recover all the bonuses awarded to Hayes in the period of his misconduct. The judge instead applied a figure of around 35%, representing the value gained by Hayes as a consequence of criminal misconduct.

Matthew Frankland, partner at Byrne and Partners, acted for a defendant acquitted in the UBS Libor 2 Trial. He noted that the SFO had been unusually tenacious in the confiscation case.

Frankland said: ‘It seems the SFO’s approach to Mr Hayes’ confiscation has been as aggressive as it was to his trial. The pursuit by them of the engagement ring he gave to his wife is a fairly unprecedented example.’

Costs were not determined in the judgment. Hayes is serving 11 years in prison following his conviction in August 2015 for conspiring to manipulate Libor.

Readers' comments (3)

  • It appears the confiscation order was based on a calculation of what the defendant personally had gained (in terms of bonuses etc) as a result of the manipulation of the LIBOR computations.

    That does not appear to be anything new.


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How refreshing to see a reasonable judge applying a benefit figure based on what the defendant had factually personally received as a result of the alleged crime, rather than some fictitious figure conjured up by the prosecution for publicity.
    This should pave the way for confiscation appeals where judges have simply gone along with unreasonable prosecutors.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Surely the engagement ring is his wife's property?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (3)
  • Save

Lord Keen

LAA invitation highlights yet another ‘advice desert’

26 October 2016By

Invitation issued for Cambridgeshire as Ministry of Justice says it is considering LASPO review date.

Mr Justice Turner

City firm defeats £15m negligence claim over extent of retainer

26 October 2016By

Former Ernst and Young partner sought to make a claim in relation to insurance settlements.

David Green

SFO says ‘independence is crucial’ amid takeover fears

26 October 2016By

David Green tells justice committee that Serious Fraud Office must retain Roskill method.

Browse over 4,300 law jobs Get jobs by email


Sign up for email news alerts

Daily Update. Keep abreast of the latest developments that affect the profession

Legal Services

Browse the magazine

Current Issue

The Gazette offers you up-to-the-minute national and international news, opinion, features, in-depth articles plus a jobs and appointments section.

Please click the link below for a digital edition