The Law Society’s Annual Commercial Litigation Conference explored forthcoming legal reform that focus on consumer protection.

During a packed panel session concerning product safety and liability law, Professor Solène Rowan, the law commissioner for commercial and common law, announced provisional proposals to 'overhaul' product liability in England and Wales. Sophie George, deputy director, product regulation policy at the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (DBIST), also provided insight into parallel reforms to improve product safety regulations. The panel was moderated by Andrew Austin, who leads Freshfields’ London disputes practice.

The mass claims panel touched on another Law Commission review covering the consumer mass claims regime. James Raeside, partner at Freshfields; Shazia Yamin, partner at Mishcon de Reya; and Brandon Deme, co-founder and director of Factor Risk Management, offered a range of perspectives on emerging trends and the reforms likely to shape the future of group proceedings.

In this article, we look at how these and other forthcoming reforms may significantly alter the landscape for consumer claims.

Accountability for product safety throughout the supply chain

DBIST has recently held consultation exercises on reforms to product safety regulations and its enforcement and surveillance. To help ensure 'proactive action from everyone in the supply chain to protect consumers', the product safety consultation proposes extending accountability to additional intermediaries. The new framework will place duties on three categories of supply chain actor: producers, onward suppliers (replacing and expanding the current 'distributor' concept and explicitly including fulfilment service providers) and online marketplaces. The duties for producers and onward suppliers will broadly follow the current regime but online marketplaces will be subject to additional duties. This recognises the increasing importance of online marketplaces in supplying products to consumers.

Product liability for the digital age

The Law Commission’s consultation on reforming product liability includes provisional proposals (the proposals) to revise many of the existing definitions in the current framework under the Consumer Protection Act 1987 (the CPA). The reforms echo aspects of the EU’s revised Product Liability Directive (PLD2), which member states must implement before 9 December 2026, but there are notable differences.

Changing the definition of product

The consultation proposes extending the definition of 'product' to recognise that '[c]onsumers are now exposed to a much wider range of products that similarly combine risk and benefit, including software embedded in medical devices, autonomous vehicles, AI, and social media platforms'. As a result, a product would be broadly defined to include:

(i) software and AI systems;

(ii) the design components and features of social media and other online platforms; and/or

(iii) to future-proof the CPA 'any other thing (digital or otherwise) that is designed or developed to perform a specific function for users'.

The proposed provision is broader than the approach in PLD2, and the Law Commission notes stakeholders’ concerns that including a wider range of technologies would unduly expand the reach of the CPA regime. Despite these concerns, the consultation insists this change is necessary to ensure CPA recognises the changing nature of the supply chain caused by emerging technologies.

New categories of defendants

The definition of 'producer' would also be widened, and three new classes of potential defendants would be added to reflect the increasing ways in which consumers purchase products. The three new categories of defendant would be:

(i) UK authorised representative;

(ii) fulfilment service providers (entities offering at least two of the following: (i) warehousing; (ii) packaging; (iii) addressing; and (iv) dispatching of a product, but excluding postal services); and

(iii) core participants (a broad category encompassing supply chain actors who have (amongst other matters) played a significant role in bringing the product to market and had sufficient control over distribution).

A tiered liability regime would apply whereby fulfilment service providers and core participants would only be liable where no UK producer, own-brander, importer or authorised representative can be identified.

Consumer rights

Source: Getty

Reviewing the defect concept

Under the CPA, a product is defective if its safety is not such as persons generally are entitled to expect. The Law Commission proposes retaining this test, while supplementing it with seven non-exhaustive principles and adding further relevant circumstances for consideration. There would also be recognition of three specific purposes to guide interpretation, including that the CPA aims to allocate the risks for defective products so that consumers who suffer damage can obtain effective compensation without needing to prove fault.

Relaxing the rules of evidence

The CPA requires the claimant to prove that the relevant product was defective and that the defect caused recoverable damage. There is no requirement to show fault on the part of the defendant. The Law Commission considers that emerging technologies create new difficulties for consumers establishing a defect and therefore proposes making it easier for a claimant to satisfy this requirement in certain cases. This would be achieved through a rebuttable presumption of defect arising where: (i) it is arguable that the product is defective; (ii) the facts relied on are not fanciful; (iii) the claimant faces 'exceptional evidential difficulties'; and (iv) the risks of harm are not so widely known as to be 'socially acceptable'. If the presumption applies and the defendant accepts the alleged defect, the courts would, subject to proof of causation of damage and any defences, apportion the risks between the parties, with equal liability as the starting point.

The Law Commission also seeks views on the introduction of a rebuttable presumption of a fact relevant to defect and/or causation where a claimant can show that there is an asymmetry of information in the defendant’s favour and that it would be fair for the defendant to bear the burden of rebutting the presumption.

Narrowing available defences

The Law Commission proposes retaining the existing defences under the CPA, with adaptations to reflect emerging technologies. The development risk defence is recognised as an important safeguard to ensure an appropriate balance of risk between businesses and consumers. It applies where it can be shown that the state of knowledge at the relevant time (typically at the time of distribution) was not such that a producer of products of the same description might be expected to have discovered the defect. Under the proposals, the defence would be limited so that it would not apply where the defendant subsequently renders the product defective, for example through software updates.

New classes of recoverable damage

Three proposals on damage are particularly significant for consumer claims. First, the £275 threshold for property claims would be removed, bringing low-value claims that could be aggregated in collective proceedings within the regime. Secondly, data loss would become recoverable. Thirdly, psychiatric harm would be compensable where it amounts to a medically recognised psychiatric illness, subject to guardrails for recovery. The final two changes would significantly widen the scope of losses that could be recovered.

Opt-out consumer class actions

As part of its Consumer Action Plan, DBIST has asked the Law Commission to examine the introduction of a consumer mass claims regime, which could include an opt-out procedure. At present, the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) mass claims mechanism is the only opt-out collective action and it is limited to competition law claims. Outside the CAT, collective consumer claims are generally pursued through alternative mechanisms, such as group litigation orders, representative proceedings or through individual test cases. The Law Commission’s Terms of Reference for the project indicate that it will examine ways to improve consumers’ access to redress in the courts. The objective of any new regime seeks to ensure damages are distributed to the affected class and promotes the efficient conduct of proceedings at proportionate costs. These aims will be important to consider as cases using the current CAT opt-out procedure have in some cases resulted in unmeritorious claims reaching court, excessive legal costs and limited compensation for the class. These and other concerns about the operation of current mass claims mechanisms have prompted other parallel reviews. The Government is assessing reforms to the CAT opt-out regime to achieve simpler and swifter redress, the DBIST is examining the case for a Consumer Ombudsman for claims outside the regulated sector, and the Solicitors Regulation Authority has consulted on proposals relating to third-party funding.

On the horizon

The implications for businesses involved in the supply chain of an expanded product liability regime covering low-value claims, combined with a potential opt-out consumer claims regime, would be significant – although commentators have noted that product liability claims, which typically rely on individual questions of causation and damage, are often unsuitable for adjudication as mass claims.

The proposals to introduce a new, opt-out procedure for consumer claims generally, mirroring the currently procedure for competition claims in the CAT, would in any event result in a dramatic change to consumer-facing businesses’ exposure if enacted. As Law Society president Brett Dixon notes, any new consumer claims regime must have safeguards that work 'for both claimants and defendants', and has urged the Law Commission to weigh any new regime against the existing routes for resolving disputes.

Reforms relating to consumer claims will reach pivotal junctures during 2027. On product safety, the government is likely to confirm new regulations in this area. The product liability consultation closes on 14 January 2027, with final recommendations expected in late 2027. The government will then be required to respond to those recommendations with around two-thirds of proposals typically followed. On mass claims, the Law Commission’s work is at an earlier stage, but provisional proposals are expected in late 2027.

At this time of important change for consumer claims, particularly as the law responds to new issues arising from emerging technologies, stakeholders should engage with the various feedback exercises and assess how the reforms interact. Taken together, a more claimant-friendly product liability regime, tougher product safety rules, reforms to CAT procedures for competition claims and the introduction of a general consumer opt-out regime could significantly reshape the landscape for consumer claims.

 

Andrew Austin, Simon Duncombe, James Raeside, Laura Feldman, Freshfields