MPs today urged the government to review whether defence solicitors are unfairly using the threat of 'fundamental dishonesty' to get claims dropped.

In its wide-ranging report on access to justice, the Commons justice select committee recommends the establishment of a 'national legal service'. But the committee was also concerned at the use of allegations of fundamental dishonesty - a finding of which can result in personal injury claimants being held liable for the defendant’s costs.

The claimant community has long argued that dishonesty allegations are being advanced in order to deter individuals with a legitimate case from pursuing it, because of the fear of being saddled with these costs. The committee acknowledged the point that allegations are being made even where cases are not clearly fraudulent.

The report recommends that the government should ‘review the operation, and concerns about weaponisation, of the fundamental dishonesty rules within qualified one-way costs shifting (QOCS), including whether the present framework provides appropriate and equivalent safeguards against unreasonable conduct by defendants’.

The committee further endorses the QOCS regime by saying ministers should look to expand its scope to include claims in the county court or High Court relating to discrimination and abuse. ‘Qualified one-way costs shifting is vital for enabling individuals to pursue claims without facing the full deterrent effect of adverse costs,' the report states. ‘We are persuaded that the distinction between personal injury litigation and categories of claim including discrimination, abuse, non-medical professional negligence and judicial review is becoming increasingly difficult to justify from an access to justice perspective.’

MPs also called for a review of the level and scope of fixed recoverable costs to determine whether they adequately reflect the actual cost of conducting litigation. There should be a mechanism for their regular review and ministers should clarify whether fixed fees should apply to housing claims.

On clinical negligence, the committee was ‘highly sceptical’ that the introduction of a ‘no-fault’ compensation system would benefit patients or help control costs.

The Association of Personal Injury Lawyers said the committee's inquiry confirmed that civil justice policy has made genuine personal injury claims harder to pursue and, in some areas, economically unviable. ‘The committee has firmly acknowledged the concerns we raised in evidence about what it describes as the ‘weaponisation’ of the rules on fundamental dishonesty by some defendants. The government now has to consider a review, which is a very positive step forward,’ said Guy Forster, APIL’s president.

The organisation supported the recommendation for a review of fixed costs, saying this has been a significant barrier to access to justice for injured people. ‘Since 2013 there has been a 42% rise in inflation, yet for many injured people the amount of legal costs they can recover from the wrongdoer has not increased at all,’ added Forster.