I refer to Brian Craig’s comments alluding to the creation of a ‘cottage industry’ in respect of criminal legal aid firms (see [2008] Gazette, 9 October, 3). Such a view is unqualified and is also patronising towards smaller criminal practices. Mr Craig apparently believes that larger firms should be entitled to more work on the spurious basis that they can deal more efficiently with increased volumes. This is despite the absence of conclusive empirical research to support such a notion.

My firm was established several years ago and we have always made, and continue to make, reasonable profits. Smaller firms continue to play a vital role in the provision of criminal legal aid by offering a high degree of professional service and choice for the public.

It seems Mr Craig and other members of the Association of Major Criminal Law Firms are not content to play by the normal rules of business and persist in demanding a ‘fixed market’ which is favourable to themselves. Perhaps Mr Craig et al should recall the days when their firms were small and they espoused the virtues of the free market and competition.

If the larger firms can no longer make a profit, I can reassure Mr Craig that there are many high-quality small firms willing to take up any slack which may be caused by the absence of firms such as his.

David O’Reilly, David O’Reilly Solicitors, Salford