Fans of The Godfather trilogy will be familiar with the concept of ‘omertà’ – a code of silence that means never speaking about the mafia. In a speech a few years ago, Lord Justice Birss jokingly applied the term to barristers – saying that ‘a weird kind of omertà’ exists when it comes to counsel’s costs: barristers do not challenge one another’s fees. 

Rachel Rothwell

Rachel Rothwell

If you ask barristers about this, they roll their eyes exasperatedly and tell you it is nonsense, citing plenty of occasions when they launched themselves at opposing counsel like a rabid dog, savaging their brief fee. But they will also acknowledge that such attacks work rather better if your opponent’s bill is much higher than your own. Very often, however, the two sets of fees will be broadly similar, which is not surprising given that barristers on each side have spent the same amount of time in court, usually with comparable levels of preparation. So there is not necessarily that much to argue about.

At a recent conference, costs expert Dominic Regan highlighted a wry comment by Lord Justice Males in relation to legal costs. Giving the lead judgment in Athena Capital v Secretariat for the Holy See (costs) [2022] EWHC Civ 1061, with which Birss LJ and Lord Justice Peter Jackson agreed, Males LJ expressed surprise that for a hearing that had been listed for two days and concluded in one, the total costs of the appeal came to a staggering £730,000. 

He remarked that it was ‘a striking feature’ that ‘although almost every possible point has been taken on both sides in the course of this appeal, there has been no challenge either to the appellants’ solicitors’ hourly rates or to the brief fees and other fees charged by their counsel’. The appellants’ solicitors’ costs were £175,000. Fees for leading and junior counsel were over £200,000. The respondent’s solicitors’ costs were £100,000, while counsel’s fees (leading and two junior counsel) came to £215,000. Eye-watering figures.

In the context of recoverable costs, the overarching rule is that both solicitors’ and barristers’ fees should be reasonable and proportionate. Solicitors’ fees are easier to scrutinise, however. They are largely charged by the hour and such charges are assessed against the official Guideline Hourly Rates (GHR), with any departure needing to be justified. Yet much to the annoyance of the solicitors’ profession, no such fun-spoiling GHRs exist for barristers, arguably leaving the latter in a cosier costs position. Now all this is about to change. Last month the Civil Justice Council launched a consultation on introducing GHRs for counsel. Cue much groaning from the bar.

Barristers have always vehemently opposed GHRs for their fees and the CJC did acknowledge difficulties. The biggest problem is that barristers charge their brief fee as a lump sum, a figure that incorporates more than a simple calculation of the hours they expect to work. It reflects the all-consuming nature of the trial period – often burning the midnight oil – as well as the cost of blocking out days in the diary, which may end up as dead time if a case settles early and the barrister is left twiddling their thumbs. The CJC is alive to these concerns and promises that the new GHRs will help to inform, but ‘not necessarily dictate’, what a reasonable brief fee would be.

The CJC’s decision on precise rates is especially important for certain parts of the bar. Claimant personal injury lawyers, for example, depend heavily on the fees that they recover from losing defendants. At the commercial bar, however, a barrister’s remuneration is unlikely to be limited to recovered costs and they will receive further payment from their own client.

Less controversially, the consultation also contained welcome news for solicitors involved in ‘extremely complex, high-value commercial work’, with a proposal for a new, higher GHR band here. The CJC is seeking help to calculate the precise rate. It has asked consultees to say how many of their cases would qualify for this new category and what they charge. The consultation runs until 19 January, and solicitors hoping to benefit from this new top rate for recoverable costs should ensure the CJC has all the information it needs to get the figures right. 

 

Rachel Rothwell is editor of Gazette sister magazine Litigation Funding