A holidaymaker hit by a falling coconut palm while lying on a sun lounger in Sri Lanka is suing her former lawyers, claiming they messed up her chance to claim £4.5 million in compensation.
Claire Saywell was sunbathing with her husband at the four-star Club Hotel Dolphin resort in the western town of Waikkal in 2017 when the 50ft coconut palm tree came down on top of her.
She described how her legs were smashed and bent backwards at the knees in a 'v-shape' by the weight of the falling trunk crashing through her lounger and she had to undergo emergency surgery in the Sri Lankan capital Columbo before being flown back to her home in Sittingbourne, Kent.
Saywell, who worked as an insurance consultant, retained national firm Slater and Gordon UK, to help her sue Tui, the agent she booked the trip through. She then sued her erstwhile lawyers for £4.5m, alleging that she lost her chance to claim when they missed a crucial deadline due to serving legal documents to the wrong email address.
London’s High Court heard last week that while Slater and Gordon UK Ltd has admitted breach of duty for having 'failed to validly serve Saywell’s claim form in her personal injury claim,' the firm is disputing that it owes any money on the basis that she probably would have lost her case.

In a preliminary hearing, Howard Elgot, for Saywell, told the judge, Master John Dagnall: 'This is a professional negligence claim by Mrs Saywell against her previous solicitors. Breach of duty by the defendant is admitted. They failed to validly serve Mrs Saywell’s claim form in her personal injury claim against Tui UK Ltd and her claim was struck out.'
The court heard that the defendant maintains that the falling of the tree was a natural disaster caused by a sudden gust of strong winds and not influenced by any human factor and that therefore there was no want of care by the hotel or its subcontractors.
Asking for permission to enlist an expert arborist - who had earlier looked at the evidence in the claim against Tui - to make a report about the state of the tree at the time it fell, the barrister said that the expert had previously said: 'It was clear that in order to secure some form of utility line, a spike and concrete had been driven into the base of the tree…this had caused rot and damage to the trunk.'
He explained that 'these trees would not usually fall over in high winds, unless of course they were already rotten,' adding that 'in his view a lay person could note the damage being done to the tree'.
'We say we had an exceptionally good chance of succeeding against Tui, whereas my learned friend says we had a terrible chance,' he told the judge. 'With a finalised report and full lay evidence, Mrs Saywell is confident of showing that her chances of success would have been in excess of 90%.'
However, Clare Elliot, for Slater and Gordon UK Ltd, told the judge that the planned case against TUI 'didn’t exceed the 51% likelihood of success', adding that the £4.5m damages figure is also 'highly contested'.
Master Dagnall, granting Mrs Saywell permission to call the expert arborist, said: 'The defendants failed to serve the claim form in time, with the result that the claim was struck out,' he added, describing the claim against the lawyers as a 'loss of a chance claim'.
'It is common ground that the question is the chance of the claimant [having achieved] a successful settlement or success at trial. There is no suggestion that her prognosis has improved recently.'
The court also heard that the two sides will try to settle the case through alternative dispute resolution if possible.
Outside court, expanding on the circumstances of the missed deadline which led to the case against Tui failing, Elgot said: 'The defendants served using the wrong email address for Tui’s solicitors. As a result the claim against Tui was struck out'.























No comments yet