A judge has lamented the £1 million costs accumulated in a 10-year boundary dispute over a small strip of land with ‘extremely limited' value.

In a short judgment in Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor, Mr Justice Tappin dismissed an appeal over a costs order. The litigation concerned some 45 square metres of land along a 60-metre boundary, consisting of 'either grass, scrub or tree and of extremely limited (if any) usable or other value’, he said.
The parties ‘have been in litigation about that strip of land since 2016, and the appellant claims to have spent over £1m in legal costs, while the respondents have spent a six-figure sum even though for much of the litigation they have been representing themselves’.
In a substantive judgment in 2022, Recorder Dagnall noted that 'boundary disputes are often said to result in an expenditure of time, cost and energy wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the area of land in dispute,' the judgment said. 'That is certainly true of this dispute.’
Read more
In the latest round, the appelllant, Mary Egan, sought to set aside an order for the respondents to pay one third of her costs of a 2017 hearing and substitute an order that the respondents pay her costs on the indemnity basis.
Dismissing the first ground of appeal, in which Egan argued the judge erred in concluding that the litigation had been a 'score draw', Tappin said he did ‘not consider that either party can be said to have been successful or unsuccessful’.
Dismissing the remaining grounds, Tappin added: ‘While I entirely agree with the appellant that the use of abusive language towards opposing lawyers and their staff, or towards judges and court staff, is deplorable and unacceptable, I do not agree that the way in which the judge dealt with these matters means that his decision was wrong in the relevant sense.’
The trial judge was ‘best placed to assess the way in which the first respondent had conducted himself’, Tappin concluded.























No comments yet