The Solicitors Regulation Authority has been urged not to abandon the idea of separating management and compliance roles in firms, after immediate plans were put on hold in the face of strong opposition.

The Legal Services Consumer Panel acknowledges there were issues with the proposal put forward by the SRA and that smaller firms could have faced extra costs. But the organisation stresses that there is a serious cost to consumers when issues arise at firms caused by a lack of internal oversight and supervision.

Writing in a blog, LSCP member Adhir Ramdarshan said an indefinite pause allowing this issue to ‘drift’ was not best serving consumer protection.

He said: ‘The SRA is right to pause a rule if it cannot show that it is properly targeted and proportionate. But a pause should be used to improve a safeguard, not to abandon the principle behind it.

‘That principle matters. Where one person can exercise significant control over a law firm and sign off its compliance, independent challenge is weakened. A compliance officer is there to challenge. It is difficult to challenge yourself.’

Ramdarshan said both Axiom Ince and PM Law, firms which collapsed in recent years causing a cumulative loss of £100m in client money, exposed the serious consequences when regulatory oversight and internal governance fail.

Compliance

Source: Thinkstock

The SRA’s response was to impose new rules preventing an individual with power to make ‘unilateral’ decisions from being compliance officers. The regulation, which had been due to come into force in January, would apply to most law firms with a turnover of more than £600,000 or which hold more than £2m in client money. 

But firms falling into this category said they were being saddled with a costly extra regulatory burden when they had not been responsible for the failings of others.

Ramdarshan said the panel agreed with reform opponents that the £600,000 turnover threshold was not necessarily a good proxy for consumer risk and had asked the SRA to explain its working.

But he added: ‘The danger is that legitimate concerns about the design of the rule become an argument for abandoning its purpose. Much of the recent opposition has understandably come from the firms that would bear the cost of complying. Those voices should be heard. But the consumers who bear the cost when governance fails must be heard too.’

The panel is now lobbying for the SRA to set a revised timetable for reform, publish the evidence upon which it is basing change, make revised regulations more targeted and bring consumers into the debate.

The SRA has said the new rules – which had the approval of the Legal Services Board – are paused until it has completed wider engagement on the best approach. The regulator will focus more on identifying higher risk firms and working with them on separating management and compliance roles where this is deemed necessary.