The First-Tier Tribunal has upheld a £60,000 fine handed out to a law firm whose data was stolen by hackers and posted on the dark web. The three-person panel found that the sanction made against Merseyside firm DPP Law by the Information Commissioner’s Office was ‘proportionate, effective and dissuasive’.

The tribunal said the ICO had rightly taken into account the seriousness and duration of the breaches, the sensitivity of the personal data affected and DPP’s financial position.

The panel stressed the importance of a ‘meaningful’ deterrent effect, so that firms processing sensitive personal data were made aware of the security risks involved and the duties they were under to keep files safe.

‘The prolonged nature of DPP’s deficiencies, and the inadequate organisational response when those risks materialised, demonstrate the importance of those obligations,’ said the ruling. ‘We consider that a substantial penalty was justified to encourage compliance by other organisations which might otherwise fail to address similar weaknesses in their own technical and organisational arrangements.’

The tribunal heard that a DPP remote desktop server had been targeted first in February 2022. Four months later, on 3 June, hackers gained access to the server using an administrator account which had been created under a previous case management system and remained operational. The firm’s email server stopped working a day later and access to its IT network was lost, with all files across its servers being corrupted.

On 15 July 2022, DPP became aware that a large volume of data from its network had been published on the dark web, and it reported the data breach to the ICO two days later.

The firm appealed the fine, saying the ICO had reached that figure on an erroneous factual basis, speculated, applied the wrong standard of proof, and failed properly to engage with DPP’s evidence. It further argued that the ICO had failed to treat the firm’s full cooperation as a mitigating factor and substantially increased its initial penalty calculation without giving proper reasons.

The ICO said the level of fine was justified and that DPP’s status as a regulated solicitors’ firm was relevant to culpability because law firms dealing with confidential client information should be particularly conscious of regulatory and security obligations.

The tribunal found the penalty did not exceed what was appropriate and proportionate in all the circumstances, and that DPP had not shown that the ICO ought to have exercised its discretion differently. The appeal was dismissed.