A magistrate has been issued with a formal warning for misconduct after he was found to have ‘repeatedly’ made comments which challenged an HMCTS official’s ‘integrity, professionalism and judgment’. 

Laptop scales

A complaint was made that Michael Dunstan had in written and verbal communications with the HMCTS magistrates’ expenses team ‘questioned the integrity, professionalism, impartiality and competence of HMCTS officials’ and suggested he had been victimised. Dunstan’s communications were considered to border on harassment, a spokesperson for the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office said.

Dunstan denied any inappropriate conduct or discriminatory behaviour.

The JCIO said: ‘He maintained that his comments were based on genuine concerns arising from decisions relating to his expenses claims. However, he accepted that one issue was not attributable to the HMCTS official concerned and apologised.’

Dunstan, who had a previously unblemished conduct record for more than 23 years, was entitled to raise his concerns but his comments ‘went beyond reasonable criticism and ‘failed to treat a HMCTS official with fairness, respect and professionalism’, the investigation found.

The magistrate’s conduct did not amount to harassment but was ‘sufficiently serious’ to constitute misconduct.

The JCIO said: ‘The guide to judicial conduct requires judicial office holders to treat others fairly and respectfully and to act professionally and courteously. The statement of expected behaviour annexed to the guide also reminds judicial office holders to be mindful of how their words and behaviour may affect others.’

Mr Justice Keehan, on behalf of the lady chief justice, and with the lord chancellor’s agreement issued Dunstan with a formal warning.