A law firm has resisted a professional negligence claim after its former client was denied an 18-month extension to get his evidence together.
Ruling in Ingram v Trethowans LLP, Mrs Justice Heather Williams DBE upheld an earlier judgment that the application was ‘unrealistic’ in light of the lengthy history of the matter.
Claimant Andrew Ingram, who appeared in person, had been represented by the south west firm in a clinical negligence claim against various NHS hospitals over ophthalmic treatment. Ingram alleged that the firm was negligent in not issuing proceedings by the expiry of the limitation period in December 2017.
The parties agreed extensions before Ingram was set a deadline to serve a compliant particulars of claim. Ingram applied for a further 18 months to file medical evidence, an application that was rejected by Master Eastman for being out of time and unrealistic. The master also said that Ingram had failed to comply with a previous court order.
Williams ruled that the master was wrong to reject the application on the basis of a missed deadline (the application was actually in time) and previous non-compliance.
But the finding that the application was unrealistic was upheld, effectively ending Ingram’s claim.
Ingram had explained that his current treating doctor had agreed to prepare an expert’s report on a pro bono basis within four months. The claimant further said he had an agreement from a solicitors' firm that it would act for him once he had obtained the report.
When asked why he had not asked the doctor to prepare a report earlier, Ingram said he was focused on starting the claim and then he thought it would be ‘rude’ when the claim was struck out and his case might not be heard.
The judge said that she would have expected the report to be available already and no good reason had been produced for the delay. The one letter from the doctor had said he was willing to produce the report ‘if instructed by your solicitors’. This provided a fundamental issue, as those solicitors would act under a CFA only if Ingram could first provide a supportive medical report.
The judge said she was not persuaded that granting an extension of time would result in the claimant obtaining the necessary expert medical report and a CPR-compliant particulars of claim.
‘The plan that he describes for obtaining this report is undermined, rather than supported, by the material he has provided, and it is neither credible nor convincing,’ she added. ‘It seems to me that he is seeking a lengthy period to do so in the hope that something will turn up.
‘In the circumstances I can have no confidence of a supportive report materialising within a reasonable time scale. Accordingly, I conclude that the master was right to refuse the requested extension of time on the basis that it was unrealistic. Accordingly, the appeal must fail.’























