The Justice Committee’s recent warning that legal aid is a 'service in managed decline' and its criticism of the government’s response to its recommendations are a damning indictment. The committee’s report is the latest in a long line of critical reviews concerning access to justice in England and Wales, following equally negative criticism from the Public Accounts Committee, National Audit Office, the Bellamy Review and the Bach Commission. Even the Ministry of Justice’s own Post-Implementation Review of LASPO acknowledged the challenge the Act posed to access to justice.

However, research conducted by the World Justice Project, commissioned as part of the Nuffield Foundation’s Public right to justice (PRTJ) programme, shows that the justice gap has persisted for decades and that, while the tightening of legal aid has been a key contributor to that gap, it is only one part of a faltering system. It supports our call for a properly resourced end-to-end justice system, one that provides visible entry points, timely advice, effective referrals and routes to redress, including early off-ramps to avoid more costly approaches to resolving civil justice disputes. Reanalysing data from existing legal needs surveys, Understanding the justice needs gap in England and Wales argues that giving people the access to justice they deserve and helping them resolve their problems isn’t only procedurally fair, it is socially just.
The findings from the World Justice Project report show that, although more than one-third (34%) of adults experienced a serious civil legal problem in a four-year period, many fail to get the help they need. These ‘legal’ problems, often concerning housing, family or relationship breakdown, and accidents or health, are problems of everyday life with far-reaching consequences for the individuals, families and businesses directly involved. These include economic and material harm, impacts on personal well-being, and strains on relationships. The consequences and costs of these hardships can also spill over into other public services, such as health services and local authority housing.
Concerningly, the research highlights that despite being a fundamental pillar of the rule of law, the justice system of England and Wales commands little trust among those with experience of trying to resolve a legal problem. Less than a third of people with such experience trust the competence of justice system actors, and only one in ten believe the system would treat them fairly.
The research follows several other reviews commissioned as part of our PRTJ programme. These include a historical review of previous attempts to reform the system to improve access to justice, which found that such efforts have largely failed to shift the dial. Another review highlights the disruptive impact of the rapid adoption of AI across the justice system, including for people who are ineligible for legal aid yet cannot afford to pay for advice privately. Collectively, our research points to the need for a more fundamental, root-and-branch review of the civil justice system.
It would be wise for such a systems wide review to adopt the recommendations coming out of the Understanding the justice needs gap research which calls for:
- Adopting a people-centred justice approach and designing services around those facing the greatest barriers to accessing justice
- Reframing how we measure justice system effectiveness to include whether people's problems are resolved fairly, rather than simply counting the number of completed cases
- Better integrating advice services and dispute-resolution pathways to provide clearer, simpler routes to resolving problems
- Placing an onus on government to be transparent about how policy and funding decisions affect access to justice, and who may be most affected by them
This call for systemic reform does not detract from the need for better resourcing of legal aid. Research we and others have supported have explicitly called for that. Recent research led by UCL’s Dr Anna Tsalapatanis show how reduced funding has restricted access to representation and weakened vital support when people need to go to court. The funding of legal advice should be front and centre in any discussion about access to justice.
Ash Patel is justice programme head at the Nuffield Foundation
























No comments yet