The High Court has ruled that two litigants in person should be able to recover the cost of an AI legal research tool which helped them largely win their appeal.

Tenants appealing a contract issue with their housing association had borrowed money to cover £1,488 for a subscription to the legal research tool, described as from a well-known, major supplier.

When they were successful in their appeal, they sought to recover the cost, saying the expenditure was incurred specifically for the purposes of this litigation and was used to identify authorities, conduct legal research and assist in the preparation of submissions.

Ruling on the matter in Foster & Anor v Wargrave on Thames Housing Association Ltd, Mr Justice Sweeting said one of the questions was whether the cost of the AI tool could properly be characterised as a disbursement and had been reasonably and proportionately incurred.

He stressed this was the same approach that had historically been adopted in relation to electronic disclosure platforms, document management systems, litigation support services and other technological developments.

Artificial intelligence

Tenants borrowed money to cover £1,488 for a subscription to the legal research tool

Source: iStock 

The court heard that the appellants, who are in their 70s, had been told they could not obtain legal aid, nor could they afford legal advice.

Sweeting said the subscription was used as a research and litigation support tool in connection with the preparation of their arguments and the identification of relevant authorities. They did not use a general or free LLM but instead bought a subscription which gave access to a sector-specific AI agent.

He added: ‘The written and oral submissions advanced by the appellants were careful, reasonably focused and ultimately successful on the principal issue before the court. I am satisfied that the subscription claimed made a real contribution to the proper presentation of the appellants’ case.’

The judge stressed that he was not holding that the cost of AI-assisted support was automatically recoverable. The issue would still be decided on the circumstances of the individual case: factors would include the nature of the service provided, the purpose for which it was incurred, whether it was reasonable and proportionate and its proper characterisation under established costs principles.

‘The technology may be new, but the principles governing recoverability are not,’ said Sweeting, who added that in general terms it would be an ‘odd outcome’ if legal professionals could deploy their AI resources in support of litigation but litigants in person were, in effect, precluded from using similar ones.