More people are being injured or becoming ill at work, yet far fewer are going on to make claims for compensation. The percentage of victims who become claimants dropped by almost two thirds between 2018/19 and 2024/25, the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) research found.

The reasons for this widening ‘justice gap’ are likely to be multifaceted. Some are based in policy. For example, injured workers now have much more to prove since the introduction of section 69 of the Enterprise Act, which took away their statutory right to compensation if their employer breaches health and safety regulations. They must now rely exclusively on complex common law instead.
The legal costs victims can recover have fallen significantly in real terms in recent years. While fixed costs have been a feature of personal injury claims for more than a decade, the number of claims which are uneconomic to run as a result of these costs is likely to have increased. High inflation and a continuing failure to up-rate fixed recoverable costs mean that the cost of pursuing a claim has risen significantly, while the costs which can be recovered have not.
Employers’ liability lawyers report that defendant behaviour has become more aggressive. Increased abuse of the rules on fundamental dishonesty has intimidated injured people into not taking their claims forward.
Lawyers who took part in APIL’s research also reported that injured workers are increasingly fearful about how their employers might react to a legal claim. Insecure work, including zero-hour contracts, and greater cost of living pressures, are leaving people less confident in ‘rocking the boat’. The drop in trade union membership will not have helped.
Chris, the focus of the new short film Chris’s Story for the Rebuilding Shattered Lives campaign, was new to his job when he was injured. He wanted to keep it. He also highlights an awareness problem, as he did not know he could claim and blamed himself for what happened.
Chris suffered serious head and spinal injuries when he fell from height installing a mezzanine floor into a warehouse. It took him a long time to realise that he should have been given appropriate personal protective equipment and that what happened was not his fault.
Chris’s injuries took a devastating toll on his physical and mental health. Family members eventually stepped in and urged him to seek help from solicitors, which was the turning point. Chris still lives with the consequences of his injuries, but he is back on track.
There is clearly work to be done by the PI sector to ensure injured workers are aware of their rights and that the law exists to help them turn their situation around, so far as possible. Chris’s Story should help with spreading the word. Its predecessor, Charlie’s Story, a cerebral palsy case, has been viewed more than four million times on social media.
But the Rebuilding Shattered Lives campaign also seeks to tackle bad policymaking. The films show the value of the work of the PI sector to vulnerable victims, to stamp out deeply embedded misconceptions about the purpose of redress which led to 15 years of damaging 'reforms'. We now need the sector to unify and actively get behind it.
Mike Benner is chief executive at the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL)
























No comments yet