Recent suggestions of introducing a ‘staggered’ age of consent, alongside ministerial pressure over defence advocacy, raises concerns about the government’s response to a high-profile conviction.

Hurried interventions such as these may satisfy the public’s demand for a ‘response’ from the government, but could carry unintended consequences for how justice is administered long after the headlines fade away.
It goes without saying that protecting 16 and 17-year-olds from exploitation is essential, but layering age restrictions into law would not be clear-cut. Already the law requires consent to involve freedom and capacity to choose, and specific offences protect young people against abuse by those occupying defined positions of trust.
Ministers should first establish where these protections fall short, and whether better enforcement could address those failings.
Adding age thresholds will create difficulties. If the restriction began at 24, a 23-year-old could lawfully have consensual sex with their 17-year-old partner, only for the same acidity to become criminal on their 24th birthday while the partner remained 17. So, how would existing relationships work, or will transitional arrangements exist? And will they be consistently applied regardless of sex or sexual orientation?
Furthermore, the lord chancellor’s intervention over defence advocacy raises a separate constitutional concern. No one disputes that complainants deserve dignity and to be taken seriously, and misleading stereotypes would be, one would suspect, dealt with appropriately by a judge - but defendants do have a right to properly test the prosecution’s evidence.
Judges, not ministerial pressure, should uphold the professional standards in courtrooms; and the same goes for the lawful argument one may make in a trial.
The lord chancellor calling on the Bar Standards Board to not only establish standards representing defendants accused of rape and sexual offences, but to propose disciplinary action for barristers, risks a perception that the executive’s finger is on the scales of justice.
This is yet another intervention by a government that is far too willing to impose itself on long-standing legal conventions with knee-jerk responses to much larger, often complex problems. Curtailing jury trials to reduce the court backlog is a case in point, when capacity and the under-resourced magistery is the actual problem.
So too with sexual crimes where the introduction of another prohibition, partly due to Downing Street wanting to respond to a high-profile conviction, should not replace existing laws being effectively enforced.
Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst MP is the Conservative member of parliament for Solihull West & Shirley, and shadow minister for Health & Social Care. He previously served as a British Army medical officer and barrister, and sits on the House of Commons Justice Committee
























No comments yet